Holiday Spiced Percolator Coffee

Holiday Spiced Percolator Coffee for Christmas Morning

Holiday spiced percolator coffee fills the house with cinnamon, cloves and orange on Christmas morning. The whole spices go right in the basket with the grounds.

I brew it in my own Elite Gourmet electric percolator, with no syrup or sugar. Below you will find the amounts for 4, 8 or 12 cups, electric and stovetop timing, and how to keep it smooth instead of bitter.

Jump to Recipe

Holiday spiced percolator coffee chart with basket spices, perk time guide and steps
Save this recipe card to Pinterest

At a glance

  • Time: about 5 minutes prep plus one brew cycle
  • Serves: 8 percolator cups
  • Caffeine: about the same as regular brewed coffee
  • Sweetener: none needed, guests add their own
  • Works in: electric and stovetop percolators

Why Spices Belong in the Percolator Basket

A percolator brews by pushing hot water up a tube and showering it over the coffee basket again and again. That repeated contact is why percolator coffee tastes bold. It also makes the percolator a great tool for whole spices. Each pass of hot water pulls a little more flavor out of the cinnamon sticks, cloves and orange peel, and the basket keeps them out of your cup.

Whole spices are the key word. Fine ground spices slip through the holes in the basket and leave a gritty layer at the bottom of the pot. Whole cinnamon sticks, whole cloves, slices of ginger and strips of peel stay put, and they give a cleaner, rounder flavor. When I brewed this in my Elite Gourmet, it ran a normal cycle and the spice flavor came out just right: present in every sip, but still clearly coffee.

Percolator Coffee

What You Need for 8 Cups

  • 8 cups of cold water, measured with the markings inside your percolator
  • 8 to 10 tablespoons coarse ground coffee. A medium or medium dark roast works best with spices.
  • 2 Ceylon cinnamon sticks, broken in half
  • 4 whole cloves
  • 3 thin slices of fresh ginger, or 1/4 teaspoon ground ginger mixed well into the grounds
  • 2 strips of orange peel with the white pith trimmed off
  • 1 star anise (optional, adds a soft licorice note)
  • To serve: cream, milk, brown sugar or maple syrup

Why Ceylon cinnamon? Cassia, the cinnamon most stores sell, naturally contains more coumarin. The NIH National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health notes that high amounts of coumarin may affect the liver in sensitive people. Two sticks in a pot of coffee is a small amount, but Ceylon is the gentler choice for a drink you may brew every weekend through the holidays.

A Percolator Cup Is Not a Mug

This catches a lot of people out. The cup markings on a percolator are usually about 5 to 6 ounces each, not a full 8 ounce mug. So an 8 cup batch fills roughly five standard mugs. Always go by the lines inside your pot, not your measuring cup, and if you are serving a crowd, brew more than you think you need.

Percolator cupsCoarse coffeeCinnamon sticksClovesOrange peel stripsFresh ginger slices
4 cups4 to 5 tbsp1212
8 cups8 to 10 tbsp2423
12 cups12 to 14 tbsp3634

Not sure about the coffee amount for your pot? Our full guide on how much coffee to use in a percolator and the percolator coffee to water ratio guide cover every size, and the Coffee Ratio Calculator will work it out for you.

How to Make It, Step by Step

Fill the pot. Pour cold, fresh water into the percolator up to the 8 cup line. Fit the stem and the empty basket. Starting with cold water gives the coffee more time in contact with the hot water as the pot heats, which helps the flavor.

Mix the coffee and spices. In a small bowl, toss the coarse ground coffee with the cinnamon, cloves, ginger, orange peel and star anise. Mixing them first spreads the spice evenly instead of leaving it all on top. Spoon it into the basket, level it gently, and put the spreader lid on.

Brew. On an electric percolator like my Elite Gourmet, simply close the lid, switch it on and let it run its full cycle. The light tells you when it is done and the pot moves to keep warm. On a stovetop percolator, heat over medium until the coffee starts to bubble into the glass knob, then turn the heat down so it perks slowly, roughly one bubble every few seconds. Perk for 7 to 8 minutes for a balanced cup or up to 10 minutes for a strong one. Our guide on how long to perk coffee goes deeper.

Lift the basket out. As soon as brewing finishes, carefully remove the basket and stem. Leaving wet grounds and spices sitting over hot coffee keeps extracting bitterness. Then pour into warm mugs and let everyone add cream, brown sugar or a drizzle of maple syrup.

Electric vs Stovetop: What Changes

Electric percolatorStovetop percolator
Timingautomatic, runs its own cycleyou control it, 7 to 10 minutes of perking
Strength controlmore coffee or more spice in the basketperk time plus coffee amount
Risk of bitternesslower, heat is regulatedhigher if it boils hard
Best forholiday mornings and easy hostingcamping and cabin trips

Both work for this recipe. With an electric model you adjust strength by changing the amount of coffee or spice rather than the time. If you are taking this on a trip, our camping percolator guide has tips for brewing over a fire.

How to Keep It Smooth, Not Bitter

Percolators have a reputation for bitter coffee, but most of the time the cause is simple. On the stove, a hard rolling boil over extracts the grounds, so keep the perk slow. Grind size matters too: fine coffee clogs the basket and turns harsh, so use a coarse grind. See how to grind coffee for a percolator and these 9 tips for smooth percolator coffee if your pot tends to taste sharp.

ProblemLikely causeFix
Spices too strongtoo many clovesKeep cloves to 4 per 8 cups, they dominate fast
Spices too faintspices on top of the grounds onlyMix spices through the coffee before brewing
Gritty cupground spice or fine coffeeUse whole spices and a coarse grind
Bitter or flatover perked or basket left inShorter perk, remove the basket right away
Next pot tastes spicedspice oils left behindWash the basket and run a water only cycle

Serving Ideas for a Holiday Morning

Set the percolator out on the table with a small coffee bar beside it: a jug of warm milk, cream, brown sugar, maple syrup, a few extra cinnamon sticks to use as stirrers and a bowl of orange peel curls. Guests can make their cup as plain or as sweet as they like. For the people who want something richer, a spoonful of homemade gingerbread syrup turns a cup into a quick gingerbread coffee, and leftover spiced coffee makes a great base for a homemade peppermint mocha. Chill any leftovers for an iced percolator coffee the next day.

Cleaning Up After Spiced Coffee

Spice oils cling to metal, and the next morning your plain coffee can taste faintly of cloves. Wash the basket, stem and spreader in warm soapy water right after brewing. If you notice any leftover aroma, run one cycle with just water. For a deeper clean, here are 11 ways to clean a percolator.

A Note on Caffeine

Spices do not change the caffeine. A percolator cup of about 5 ounces has roughly the same caffeine as the same amount of regular brewed coffee, which the Mayo Clinic puts at around 96 mg for a full 8 ounce cup. With a pot on the table it is easy to keep refilling, so if you have guests who are sensitive to caffeine or pregnant, brew a second pot with decaf. The spices taste just as good.

More Percolator and Holiday Recipes

For more ways to use your percolator, try these 10 creative coffee percolator recipes or learn which coffee suits a percolator best. Save this recipe to your Christmas & Holiday Drinks board on Pinterest so it is ready for Christmas morning.

Holiday spiced percolator coffee pin with a stainless steel electric percolator
Pin it for later
Stainless steel electric coffee percolator on a kitchen shelf

Holiday Spiced Percolator Coffee

A festive pot of coffee brewed with whole Ceylon cinnamon, cloves, ginger and orange peel mixed into the percolator basket.
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 12 minutes
Total Time 17 minutes
Servings: 8 cups
Course: Drinks
Cuisine: American

Ingredients
  

  • 8 cups cold water use your percolator markings
  • 8 to 10 tablespoons coarse ground coffee medium or medium dark roast
  • 2 Ceylon cinnamon sticks broken in half
  • 4 whole cloves
  • 3 slices fresh ginger or 1/4 tsp ground ginger
  • 2 strips orange peel pith removed
  • 1 star anise optional
  • 1 pinch ground nutmeg optional
  • cream, brown sugar or maple syrup to serve

Method
 

  1. Pour the cold water into the percolator and fit the stem and basket.
  2. Mix the coffee with the cinnamon, cloves, ginger, orange peel, star anise and nutmeg, then spread it in the basket and cover with the spreader lid.
  3. Heat over medium until it begins to perk, then lower the heat to keep a slow, steady perk.
  4. Perk for 7 to 8 minutes for medium strength, or up to 10 minutes for strong coffee. Electric percolators: run a normal cycle.
  5. Remove from the heat, lift out the basket and stem, and serve with cream and sweetener on the side.

Notes

Wash the basket after brewing so spice oils do not flavor your next pot. For 12 cups, use 12 to 14 tablespoons coffee and increase the spices by half.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you put spices in a percolator?

Yes. Mix whole spices like cinnamon sticks, cloves, ginger slices and orange peel into the coffee grounds in the basket. Avoid large amounts of fine ground spice, which can slip through the basket.

Does this work in an electric percolator?

Yes. I make it in my Elite Gourmet electric percolator. Add the water, put the coffee and spice mix in the basket and run a normal cycle, then remove the basket when it finishes.

How much coffee do I use for 12 cups?

About 12 to 14 tablespoons of coarse ground coffee, with 3 cinnamon sticks, 6 cloves, 3 strips of orange peel and 4 slices of fresh ginger.

Will the spices stain or damage my percolator?

No, but their oils can linger. Wash the basket and stem after brewing and run a water only cycle if your next pot tastes spiced.

Can I add sugar to the basket?

You can add 1 to 2 tablespoons of brown sugar to the grounds, but it can make them clump. It is easier to let everyone sweeten their own mug.

Can I make it ahead?

Spiced coffee is best fresh, but you can mix the dry coffee and spice blend the night before and keep it in a sealed jar so the morning only takes a button press.

How this post was made: Yousuf brews this in his own Elite Gourmet electric percolator, and the text was drafted with help from AI writing tools, then checked and edited by Yousuf. Read our Editorial Policy. Some photos by Halyna Khomyk, hello aesthe and Rahib Yaqubov on Pexels.

Similar Posts